Every time you look at your monthly statement, you see it: a significant chunk of your hard-earned revenue eaten up by credit card processing fees. It’s a frustrating cost of doing business, but what if it didn’t have to be? Many business owners are now exploring ways to offset this expense by passing the cost to the consumer. This strategy, a form of credit card processing that charges the customer, can directly protect your profit margins and improve your cash flow. But it’s not as simple as just adding a fee. This guide will walk you through the different methods, legal rules, and customer communication strategies you need to know to do it right.

Key Takeaways

• Choose Your Method Wisely: Decide between adding a direct fee for credit card use (surcharging) or rewarding cash payments with a lower price (cash discount). Your choice affects customer perception and must comply with your state’s specific regulations.
• Follow the Rules to Stay Protected: Passing on fees is highly regulated. You must check your state’s laws, notify the card brands 30 days in advance, and ensure your system never applies a fee to debit card transactions.
• Prioritize Clear Communication: Prevent customer frustration by being transparent. Use simple signs at your entrance and checkout to announce the fee, and train your team to explain the change confidently and consistently.

What Does It Mean to Pass on Credit Card Fees?

When a customer swipes, taps, or inserts their credit card, you pay a small percentage of that sale in processing fees. While these fees seem small on each transaction, they can add up to a significant operating expense over the course of a month or year. Passing on credit card fees is simply a way to offset that expense by having the customer who uses the card cover the cost. It’s a strategy that can directly protect your profit margins and improve your cash flow, especially for businesses with tight budgets or those that handle a high volume of small transactions.

There are a few different ways to do this, but the two most common methods are surcharging and cash discounting. While they sound similar, they work in fundamentally different ways and are treated differently under the law. A surcharge adds a fee for using a credit card, while a cash discount offers a price break for paying with cash. The choice between them often comes down to state regulations and how you want to frame the cost for your customers. Understanding the distinction is the first step in figuring out if one of these programs is the right fit for your business and your clientele.

What is a Surcharge?

Think of a surcharge as a straightforward service fee for the convenience of using a credit card. When a customer chooses to pay with credit, your payment terminal automatically adds a small percentage to their total bill. This fee directly covers the processing cost you would otherwise have to pay. It’s a transparent way to show the cost associated with credit card payments.

However, you can’t just decide to add a surcharge on a whim. This practice is regulated, and some states don’t allow it at all. For example, surcharging is currently banned in Connecticut and Massachusetts. Other states have very specific rules you must follow, so it’s crucial to understand your local laws before you start.

Surcharging vs. Cash Discounts: What’s the Difference?

While a surcharge adds a fee, a cash discount program works by rewarding customers for not using a credit card. With this model, you display a regular price that already accounts for credit card processing costs. Then, you offer a discount to anyone who pays with cash or a debit card. It frames the situation as a savings opportunity rather than an extra charge, which can feel better to your customers.

The biggest advantage here is that cash discount programs are legal in all 50 states. This makes it a go-to option for businesses in areas where surcharging is restricted. Instead of adding a fee for credit, you’re simply offering a lower price for cash, which is a subtle but important distinction.

Is Passing on Processing Fees Legal?

So, you’re wondering if you can actually pass on processing fees without getting into trouble. It’s a question I hear all the time from business owners looking to manage their costs. The short answer is yes, it’s generally legal in most places, but it’s not a free-for-all. Think of it less as a simple switch you can flip and more as a regulated practice with a clear set of rules you need to follow. Getting this right is crucial for protecting your business and maintaining trust with your customers.

The regulations come from two main sources: your state government and the major credit card brands (like Visa and Mastercard). You have to comply with both to stay in the clear. It might sound like a bit of homework, but understanding these rules upfront will save you from potential fines, chargebacks, and customer complaints down the road. Let’s break down what you need to know to make an informed decision for your business.

Know Your State’s Surcharging Laws

First things first: your business’s location matters. Surcharging rules are not the same everywhere, and some states have put their foot down on the practice entirely. For example, passing on credit card fees is currently prohibited in Connecticut and Massachusetts. Other states, including New York and Texas, allow it but have very specific requirements you must follow. Because these regulations can change, your first step should always be to check the most current surcharging rules by state. This isn’t a step you want to skip, as ignoring local laws can lead to serious penalties. Make sure you have a clear understanding of what’s allowed in your specific area before you even think about programming your POS system.

Following Card Brand Rules

Once you’ve confirmed that surcharging is legal in your state, you also need to play by the rules set by the credit card companies. They have strict guidelines to ensure the practice is fair to consumers. The most important rule is that you cannot charge customers more than what it actually costs you to process the transaction, with a general cap of 4%. You also can’t apply a surcharge to debit or prepaid card transactions—it’s for credit cards only.

Transparency is also a huge part of their requirements. You must clearly notify your customers about the fee by posting signs at your store’s entrance and at the point of sale. Finally, you need to notify the card brands at least 30 days before you start.

How to Pass on Processing Costs: Your Options

If you’re tired of seeing a chunk of your revenue go toward credit card processing fees, you’re not alone. The good news is you don’t have to absorb those costs entirely. Passing them on to the customer is a common strategy, but it’s not as simple as just adding a fee to every credit card transaction. You have a few different ways to approach this, and each comes with its own set of rules and customer perceptions.

Choosing the right method depends on your business, your customers, and the laws in your state. Some options, like surcharging, involve adding a direct fee for using a credit card. Others, like cash discounts or dual pricing, focus on incentivizing customers to pay with cash by offering them a lower price. Understanding the differences is key to saving money on fees without alienating your customers or running into legal trouble. Let’s walk through the four main ways you can share these costs.

Add a Direct Surcharge

The most direct way to offset processing fees is by adding a surcharge. This is a small percentage, typically around 3%, added to a customer’s total when they choose to pay with a credit card. Your POS system can be programmed to add this fee automatically, making it a straightforward way to cover your costs on each transaction.

However, this is where you need to be careful. Surcharging is not legal in every state. As of now, it’s prohibited in Connecticut and Massachusetts, and other states have very specific rules you must follow. Before you even consider this option, you need to check your state’s specific surcharging laws to make sure you’re compliant. It’s a great way to recoup costs, but only if it’s done by the book.

Offer a Cash Discount

A cash discount program flips the script on surcharging. Instead of adding a fee for credit cards, you offer a small discount to customers who pay with cash or debit. This approach is often received more positively by customers because it feels like a reward for paying with cash rather than a penalty for using a card. You simply post the regular price for all items and let customers know they’ll save a certain percentage by not using a credit card.

This method is a fantastic alternative in states where surcharging is not allowed. It achieves the same goal—covering your processing costs—by encouraging more cash transactions. It’s a simple, customer-friendly way to reduce your credit card fees and protect your profit margins.

Use Convenience Fees

A convenience fee is a bit different from a surcharge. It’s a flat fee you can charge when a customer uses a non-standard or more convenient payment method, like paying a bill online or over the phone. You can’t add a convenience fee to a regular in-person transaction where you normally accept credit cards. It’s specifically for payment channels that you offer as an alternative to your standard process.

The rules for convenience fees are set by the major card brands, and they can be complex. For example, Visa has specific guidelines on when and how these fees can be applied. This option works well for businesses that take payments through multiple channels, but make sure you understand the card brand rules before implementing it.

Implement Dual Pricing

Dual pricing is a strategy where you display two prices for every item or service: a standard price for paying with a credit card and a lower price for paying with cash. This is different from a cash discount because the credit card price is the default, and the cash price is presented as the alternative. It’s completely transparent and gives the customer a clear choice at the point of sale.

This method is legal in all 50 states and is becoming a popular way for businesses to eliminate their processing fees entirely. By clearly posting both prices, you educate your customers on the cost of card acceptance and empower them to choose the payment method that works best for them. It’s a compliant and effective way to manage your costs.

The Pros and Cons of Passing on Fees

Deciding whether to pass processing fees to your customers is a big move. On one hand, it can seriously help your bottom line. On the other, you have to consider how your customers will react and what rules you need to follow. Let’s break down the main arguments for and against it so you can figure out what makes the most sense for your business.

Pro: Save Money and Improve Cash Flow

The biggest win here is pretty straightforward: you save a significant amount of money. Credit card processing fees can take a real bite out of your revenue, especially for small businesses where every dollar counts. By passing those costs on, you can immediately improve your cash flow and keep more of each sale. Think about what you could do with that extra money—invest in new inventory, run a marketing campaign, or give your team a raise. For many businesses, eliminating these fees isn’t just about saving a few dollars; it’s about creating more financial stability and room for growth.

Con: Risking Customer Pushback and Legal Issues

The main hurdle is how your customers will feel about it. Nobody loves seeing an extra fee on their receipt, and some might see a surcharge as a penalty for using their card. This could lead them to pay with cash or, in some cases, take their business elsewhere. Beyond customer perception, you also have to be careful with the rules. Each state has its own surcharging laws, and the major card brands have specific guidelines you must follow to the letter. It’s not as simple as just adding a fee; you have to do your homework to stay compliant and avoid potential penalties.

How to Set Up a Surcharge Program

Ready to start passing on credit card fees? Setting up a surcharge program isn’t complicated, but it requires careful attention to detail to keep everything compliant and customer-friendly. Think of it as a three-step process: getting the numbers right, updating your technology, and communicating clearly with your customers. Each step is crucial for a smooth rollout.

The goal is to offset your processing costs without creating a negative experience for your shoppers. When a customer pays with a credit card, your system will automatically add a small fee to their total bill to cover the transaction cost. Getting this right means you’ll save money on every credit card sale while maintaining trust with your clientele. The best part is you don’t have to do it alone. A reliable payment partner can walk you through the setup, ensuring your program follows all the rules from day one. Let’s break down exactly what you need to do.

Calculate Your Surcharge Rate

First things first, you need to figure out the exact percentage to add as a surcharge. This isn’t a number you can just guess. The surcharge is meant to cover your processing costs, so the rate you charge customers cannot be higher than the rate you actually pay to accept the card. Most card brands, like Visa and Mastercard, also cap the surcharge amount, typically around 3% or 4%.

To find your effective processing rate, look at your recent merchant statements or talk to your payment processor. They can help you determine the precise rate that ensures you’re only covering your costs and staying well within the legal limits. This keeps the process fair for everyone involved.

Program Your POS System

Once you have your rate, the next step is to update your payment technology. Your credit card processor is responsible for programming your point-of-sale (POS) system or payment terminal to add the surcharge correctly. This is a critical technical step that ensures the fee is applied automatically and accurately only on eligible transactions—that is, credit card payments, not debit or prepaid cards.

Working with your processor handles the heavy lifting. They’ll make sure the terminal recognizes different card types and applies the fee only when it’s supposed to. This automation prevents cashier errors, streamlines checkout, and guarantees you’re compliant with card brand rules on every single swipe, dip, or tap.

Post Clear Signage for Customers

Transparency is everything when it comes to new fees. You must clearly inform customers about the surcharge before they get to the checkout counter. The best practice is to post clear, simple signs at your store’s entrance and at the point of sale. This gives customers a heads-up and prevents any frustrating surprises when it’s time to pay.

Your signage doesn’t need to be complicated. Something as simple as, “A small fee will be applied to all credit card purchases” is often enough. This simple act of communication is required by the card brands and is also just good business. Being upfront shows respect for your customers and helps you maintain their trust.

Common Surcharging Myths, Busted

When it comes to passing on credit card fees, there’s a lot of confusing information out there. Misunderstandings can lead to unhappy customers or, even worse, legal trouble for your business. Let’s clear the air and tackle some of the most common myths about surcharging so you can make informed decisions that protect your bottom line and your reputation.

Getting the facts straight is the first step to implementing a fee program that saves you money without creating headaches. From where it’s legal to which cards you can apply fees to, knowing the rules helps you protect your business and maintain trust with your customers. Think of this as your go-to guide for separating surcharging fact from fiction, so you can move forward with confidence.

Myth: Surcharging is Legal Everywhere

This is one of the most dangerous myths for business owners. The truth is, surcharging rules vary by state. While it’s permitted in most of the U.S., it’s currently banned in Connecticut and Massachusetts. Other states, including New York, Texas, and California, have their own specific regulations you must follow. Before you even consider adding a surcharge, your first step should always be to check your local laws. These regulations can change, so staying current is key to remaining compliant and avoiding potential fines.

Myth: You Can Surcharge Debit Cards

Here’s a hard-and-fast rule you can’t ignore: you are not allowed to add a surcharge to debit card transactions. This applies even if a customer uses a debit card and it’s processed through a credit card network (for example, they don’t enter a PIN). The prohibition on surcharging debit cards is a strict regulation set by the card brands. Attempting to add a fee to a debit purchase can put your merchant account at risk. Make sure your POS system is configured to differentiate between credit and debit cards to prevent this from happening automatically.

Myth: “No-Fee” Processing Has No Costs

The idea of “no-fee” or “zero-cost” processing sounds amazing, but it’s often misleading. While these programs work by passing transaction fees to the customer, it doesn’t mean your business will pay nothing. Most processors still charge monthly account fees, PCI compliance fees, and sometimes costs for equipment or software. While you’ll save a significant amount on the variable transaction costs, it’s important to understand the full picture. Always ask for a complete breakdown of any potential payment processing fees so you know exactly what your total monthly cost will be.

How to Talk to Customers About New Fees

Introducing a new fee can feel like a tricky conversation to have with your customers. But it doesn’t have to be. With a little preparation, you can handle the change with confidence and maintain the trust you’ve worked so hard to build. The key is to be open, honest, and consistent in your communication. When customers understand the why behind the fee, they’re much more likely to be understanding. Think of it less as delivering bad news and more as being transparent about the costs of doing business. By focusing on clear communication at the checkout, training your staff, and being ready for feedback, you can make the transition smooth for everyone involved.

Be Transparent at Checkout

No one likes surprises, especially when it comes to their bill. The most important step in rolling out a new fee is to be completely transparent before the customer even gets to the register. The best way to do this is with clear, simple signage. Place a notice at your entrance and another right at the point of sale so customers are informed upfront. This simple act of setting expectations prevents confusion and frustration. When the fee appears on the screen or receipt, it won’t be a shock. Instead, it will be something they were already aware of, which helps preserve a positive checkout experience and shows you respect your customers enough to be straightforward with them.

Train Your Team to Answer Questions

Your employees are on the front lines, and they’ll be the ones answering questions about the new fee. It’s crucial to equip them with the right information so they can respond confidently and consistently. Hold a brief training session to explain why you’re implementing the program. Give them a simple, honest script to use, like, “This fee helps us cover our credit card processing costs without raising our overall prices.” When your team understands the reasoning and has a clear answer ready, they can handle customer questions calmly and professionally. This ensures every customer gets the same message and reinforces that the decision was made thoughtfully.

Prepare for Customer Feedback

Even with perfect transparency and a well-trained team, some customers may still be unhappy about a new fee. It’s important to prepare for this possibility and not take it personally. Surcharges can sometimes annoy customers, and a few might even decide to pay with cash or shop elsewhere. The best approach is to listen to their concerns with empathy. Let them know you understand their perspective and thank them for their feedback. Reiterate that the program allows you to keep your product and service prices competitive for everyone. By handling negative feedback gracefully, you show that you value your customers’ opinions and can often turn a potentially negative interaction into a positive one.

Staying on the Right Side of the Rules

Passing on processing fees can be a game-changer for your bottom line, but it’s important to do it by the book. Think of it less like a complicated legal maze and more like a simple checklist. To keep your business protected and your customers happy, you just need to follow a few key rules set by the card brands and your state. It’s all about being transparent and compliant. Let’s walk through the three essential steps to make sure you’re handling everything correctly.

Notify the Card Brands

Before you flip the switch on a surcharge program, you need to give the card brands a heads-up. Visa and Mastercard require merchants to provide at least 30 days’ notice before they start adding a fee to credit card transactions. This isn’t a step you can skip. The good news is you don’t have to call them up yourself. Your payment processor, like us here at MBNCard, handles this notification for you. It’s a crucial part of getting set up correctly and ensures you’re following the official surcharging rules from the very beginning.

Follow Your State’s Laws

This is a big one: surcharge rules are not the same everywhere. What’s perfectly fine in one state might be illegal in another. For example, surcharging is currently not allowed in Connecticut and Massachusetts. Other states, like New York and Texas, have their own specific regulations you’ll need to follow. Before you even think about adding a fee, you have to check your local laws to confirm that it’s permitted and to understand any limits on how much you can charge. A quick check now can save you from major headaches later.

Keep Accurate Records

Transparency is key to keeping both customers and card brands happy. This starts with clear communication at your place of business. You must post signs at the entrance and at the point of sale letting customers know that a fee will be applied to all credit card purchases. This prevents any surprises at the register. Beyond signage, the surcharge must also appear as a separate line item on every customer’s receipt. This not only serves as proper disclosure but also helps you maintain accurate records for your own bookkeeping, ensuring everything is clear and accounted for.

Choosing the Right Strategy for Your Business

Deciding to pass on credit card processing fees is a big step, and picking the right approach is just as important. There isn’t a single best answer for every business. The ideal strategy depends on your unique situation—your industry, your relationship with your customers, and your long-term goals. By thinking through a few key areas, you can find a solution that protects your bottom line while keeping your customers happy.

Consider Your Customers and Industry

Before you make any changes, put yourself in your customers’ shoes. How will they react to seeing an extra fee on their receipt? While saving on fees is great, you don’t want to risk damaging the customer loyalty you’ve worked so hard to build. Think about your specific clientele. Are they regulars who might be put off by a new charge, or are they one-time buyers who prioritize convenience? Also, consider the norms in your industry. If your direct competitors aren’t passing on fees, you might be at a disadvantage. Understanding your audience is the first step to making a smart choice.

Compare Surcharging vs. Cash Discounts

The two most common ways to pass on fees are surcharging and cash discount programs, and they work differently. Think of it this way: surcharging adds a fee for paying with a credit card, while a cash discount offers a reward for paying with cash. A surcharge is legally capped to cover only your processing cost—it’s not a profit center. A cash discount, on the other hand, presents the lower cash price as the standard. This can sometimes feel more positive to customers, as it frames the choice as an opportunity to save rather than a penalty to pay. The best fit depends on how you want to frame the price for your customers.

Partner with Your Processor to Get Started

You don’t have to figure all of this out on your own. A reliable payment processor is your partner in this process, guiding you every step of the way. They handle the technical side, like programming your payment terminals to apply the new rate correctly. But a great partner does more—they help you stay compliant and communicate the change effectively. They’ll help you get started correctly, ensuring you have the right signage to keep customers informed and that your team knows how to answer questions. This partnership is key to a smooth rollout that feels transparent to your customers and stress-free for you.

Related Articles

• Merchant Cash Discount Program: Myths vs. Facts
• Merchant Services: Exploring the Power of Cash Discount Programs
• Understanding Cash Discount Programs and the Role of Credit Card Processors
• Why 95% of Merchants Overpay for Credit Card Processing
• Dual Pricing Merchant Services: How Does It Work?

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the simplest way to explain the difference between a surcharge and a cash discount? Think of it this way: a surcharge adds a small fee when a customer chooses to pay with a credit card. A cash discount, on the other hand, offers a lower price to customers who choose to pay with cash. One is framed as an added cost for convenience, while the other is presented as a reward for using cash. This distinction is important because surcharging is not legal in every state, but cash discount programs are.

Will I upset my customers by adding a fee? It’s a valid concern, but transparency makes all the difference. Most customer frustration comes from surprise charges at the register. By posting clear, simple signs at your entrance and checkout counter, you give customers a heads-up. When people understand that the fee helps you cover processing costs without raising overall prices, they are generally more understanding.

Can I apply a surcharge to every card payment? No, and this is a critical rule to remember. Surcharges can only be applied to credit card transactions. You are not allowed to add a fee to debit card or prepaid card payments, even if a customer runs their debit card as credit. A properly configured payment system will automatically distinguish between card types to keep you compliant.

What’s the first thing I need to do to get started? Before you do anything else, you must check your state’s specific laws on surcharging. Regulations vary by location, and a few states prohibit the practice entirely. Confirming that it’s legal in your area is the essential first step. After that, your next call should be to your payment processor to discuss your options and begin the setup process.

Is it true that “zero-cost” processing means I won’t pay anything? While these programs can dramatically reduce your expenses by passing transaction costs to the customer, “zero-cost” can be a bit misleading. You will likely still have some fixed monthly costs, such as account fees, software charges, or PCI compliance fees. It’s always a good idea to ask for a complete breakdown of all potential charges so you have a clear picture of your total monthly investment.